How controversial comments by stars have derailed film releases

In India, where cinema is more than just entertainment, often treated with the reverence reserved for religion, actors and directors carry not just the weight of their artistry but also the burden of public responsibility.

Over the years, a pattern has emerged: one controversial comment from a celebrity, and an entire film's release can face hurdles, bans, or boycotts. These aren't just skirmishes of opinion; they are flashpoints where politics, language, regional pride, and public sentiment converge, sometimes threatening to undo months and even years of filmmaking effort.The recent uproar surrounding ‘Thug Life’, Kamal Haasan’s much-anticipated film directed by Mani Ratnam, is the latest chapter in this saga.

The ‘Thug Life’ Row: A lesson in linguistic sensitivities

In May 2025, Kamal Haasan’s comments about the Kannada language and its roots sparked widespread outrage in Karnataka. Speaking at a public event, Haasan reportedly remarked, "Kannada is a derivative of Tamil and owes much of its classical structure to Tamil traditions," a statement many Kannadigas perceived as dismissive of their linguistic heritage. Pro-Kannada groups protested immediately, calling for a ban on ‘Thug Life’ in Karnataka.

Despite the film's pan-Indian ambitions, with stars from multiple industries, including Trisha and Jayam Ravi, the controversy led to calls for a state-wide boycott. The Karnataka Film Chamber received multiple requests to stall the film's release until Haasan offered an apology.This isn’t the first time an actor's or filmmaker's words have caused a film to hit a wall. Several previous examples highlight how statements off-screen can deeply impact what unfolds on it.

Past controversies that disrupted film releases

1. Aamir Khan and ‘PK’ / ‘Dangal’In 2015, Aamir Khan’s comment about rising "intolerance" in India during an interview at the Ramnath Goenka Awards sparked political fury. He said:“As an individual, as part of this country, I am alarmed. I am afraid for my children.”His remark was met with boycott campaigns against his then-upcoming films ‘Dangal’ and ‘PK’, with some theatre owners refusing to screen his films in select regions.

Although ‘Dangal’ eventually performed phenomenally well, the backlash highlighted the fine line public figures walk in India.2. Deepika Padukone and ‘Padmaavat’In 2017, ‘Padmaavat’ faced violent opposition even before its release. Deepika Padukone, who played Rani Padmavati, stated:“We have not distorted history. Those who are protesting are doing it without watching the film.”Rajput groups, particularly the Karni Sena, were enraged, threatening violent action and vandalism.

The controversy led to bans in several states, including Rajasthan, Gujarat, and Madhya Pradesh, until the Supreme Court intervened. The film was forced to change its name from ‘Padmavati’ to ‘Padmaavat’ and include disclaimers.3. Naseeruddin Shah’s ‘Fear of Living’ and the Fallout on ‘A Wednesday’Although ‘A Wednesday’ had been released in 2008, Shah's later comments in 2018—"The death of a cow is given more importance than the death of a police officer"—provoked right-wing backlash.

Social media erupted with demands to boycott his past and future work. His upcoming theatre performances and screenings of older films were temporarily cancelled in some cities.4. Vishal Bhardwaj and ‘Haider’In 2014, ‘Haider’, based on Kashmir’s insurgency, drew controversy due to Bhardwaj’s comments on the role of the Indian Army in Kashmir. Critics accused him of being "anti-national." There were protests in Jammu and threats to theatres, leading to limited release in the region.

While Bhardwaj insisted the film was about human suffering and not politics, it did not prevent the storm.5. Mansoor Khan and ‘Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak’ (Retrospective)Though not a contemporary case, Mansoor Khan's candid remarks in a 2020 interview regarding how Bollywood had catered "too much to the North Indian audience" caused online backlash, with netizens revisiting his films and accusing him of regional bias—even though ‘QSQT’ was released decades earlier.

This shows how even retrospective comments can trigger backlash in today’s hyperconnected environment.

The High Cost of Controversy

The impact of such controversies isn't limited to hurt egos or trending hashtags. A ban or boycott—even if unofficial—translates into real losses. Producers often have to:

In the case of ‘Thug Life’, with its high-profile ensemble and multi-crore budget, even a partial ban could dent profits and impact its pan-India appeal.

Kamal Haasan, a political figure and outspoken public intellectual, has had run-ins before, notably with ‘Vishwaroopam’ (2013), which was banned in Tamil Nadu.In an era of hyper-visibility, celebrities are always a soundbite away from controversy. Some argue this restricts free speech; others contend that with influence comes responsibility. Filmmakers like Anurag Kashyap have stood by controversial statements, while others, like Sanjay Leela Bhansali, have issued apologies to keep the peace.

The ‘Thug Life’ episode is a stark reminder that in India, cinema is political. Language, religion, and regional identity are powerful triggers, and when a star speaks, the ripple effects reach millions. Until a middle ground is found, the industry will continue to navigate this uneasy terrain, where a single sentence can make or break a film’s destiny.